Carrie Underwood – “Good Girl”

24 Feb

After having been the dominant female force in country music for a good while, Carrie Underwood has been relatively quiet on the music front for the past year.  Though her highly successful Play On tour kept her more than busy, her only new music released in the past year was her appearance as a duet partner on Brad Paisley’s “Remind Me.”  The wait is now drawing to a close with the release of “Good Girl,” the first single from Underwood’s as-yet-untitled fourth album, set for a May 1 release.

“Good Girl,” essentially does what “Cowboy Casanova” did a few years prior, but does it a bit better.  Once again, Underwood plays the part of a woman warning a companion against tangling with a no-good man.  This time the lyrics largely steer clear of overtly cliché territory, while offering a few clever lines such as “His lips are dripping honey, but he’ll sting you like a bee.”  But while the song flirts with the idea of having some sort of meaning, it remains clear that the song’s main purpose is to set toes tapping, and to get the crowd singing along, which is not inherently a bad thing.  To that end, “Good Girl” serves its purpose well.

Of course, some of the typical Underwood criticisms still apply here.  Yes, the sonic treatment is bombastic as usual.  Fortunately, the production stays out of the way for the first half, leaning on a catchy guitar hook and hand clap section, before finally succumbing to the temptation to indulge in some electric guitar shredding.  More irritating are the unnecessary layers of background vocals, which give the track a murky, watered-down sound, whereas a crisp and clean edge could have made it a little better.

At the end of the day, “Good Girl” succeeds in spite of itself because it plays to Underwood’s strengths as a vocalist – simply by allowing her to rock out and show some attitude.  Indeed, the main thing that makes “Good Girl” enjoyable is the way Underwood tears into the song and owns it.  Thus, we’re left with a good single that falls a degree short of greatness, but that nonetheless succeeds in whetting appetites for new music from the ever-so-talented Carrie Underwood.

(Scores are given on a scale of 1 to 10)


About these ads

Posted by on February 24, 2012 in Single Reviews


Tags: ,

4 responses to “Carrie Underwood – “Good Girl”

  1. Collin

    March 1, 2012 at 10:00 PM

    When I heard it the first time, I was struck with two realizations. The first is that Carrie is an amazing singer who gives quite a performance on this track. The second is that the lyrics are about as one dimensional as you could possibly get. There’s an occasional glimmer of creativity here and there, but for Carrie to have the world’s best songwriters at her disposal, you’d think she would be able to find a little more depth.

  2. rowdyred

    March 8, 2012 at 6:23 PM

    Melodically this song hits a grand-slam: It’s got 4 distinct “chapters” in the melodic progression and they don’t follow in a straight line from small to big or vice versa. The choices in this arrangement are totally refreshing and made me sit up and notice!

    Accordingly, Carrie gives each section of the melody a suitably different treatment. I think it’s the most interesting song on the radio right now, at least from the standpoint that it sounds unique and she sounds ah-maze-ing. Lyrically, it is much more ordinary, but man, that extraordinary combo of music and vocalist really makes it something special.

    I give it a 9 because despite the lyrical content (or lack thereof), I will never get tired of hearing this!

  3. Travis

    March 10, 2012 at 6:28 PM

    This track is a complete mess to me. Fabricated junk to show Carrie has “attitude” Don’t get me started on how she over sings this to the max. My ears are bleeding.

  4. Michael A.

    April 29, 2012 at 1:50 AM

    I don’t know. To me, this just sounds like an outtake from a Paula Abdul album.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: